Dinner at Enoteca Pinchiorri, Michelin 3-star Restaurant in Florence, Italy

A meal at Enotecha Pinchiorri is a bucket-list item for accomplished, or aspiring, gourmands.  I (a member of the aspiring class) ate dinner at the establishment on Tuesday, May 4th, as the kickoff event in Bordeaux Index's Taste of Tuscany, a four-day encounter with the foods and wines of selected Tuscan regions.  In this post I will frame the Bordeaux Index (BI) program and revisit our experiences within the hallowed walls of Enoteca Pinchiorri.

I was introduced to Bordeaux Index and its wine-travel capabilities by one of my Decanter Yquem Weekend compatriots.   My primary contact at BI was Elly Dean, Events Coordinator and she did a wonderful job of outlining the company's capabilities in my area of interest, helping me narrow down to the trip I wanted, and then working to ensure smooth in- and post-trip experiences.  The specific event that I selected was BIs Taste of Tuscany which kicked-off with the aforementioned EP dinner, and then was followed by a day trip to Bolgheri, inclusive of two winery visits and lunch at one of the wineries; a two-day trip to Montalcino, inclusive of four winery visits, two tasting lunches and a dinner.  I thought that this would be a wonderful introduction to Tuscany.  So I bought it.  Hence the dinner at Enoteca Pinchiorri.

Enoteca Pinchiorri is a now 35-year collaboration between the Italian Giorgi Pinchiorri and Frenchwoman Anne Féolde.  The cooperation started out with Anne preparing small plates to accompany the spectacular wines on show by Giorgio, who was a sommelier of some repute, but has grown into a food-centered enterprise driven by Anne's renown as a world-class chef.  The restaurant is located in an old Florentine Palace at 87 Via Ghibellina in the heart of the old "Medici-ville."  The restaurant has three Michelin stars and was named Best Restaurant in the World in 2005.

In addition to my wife and me, the tour included a couple from England, a couple from Wales, and Elia Leonardo, our BI Minder (Elia gave us this sob story that he had just broken up with his girlfriend so the wives spent the entire trip trying to fix him up with every pretty girl that we ran into.  He enjoyed the trip more than anyone else.  Just kidding BI, he is a good guy and a keeper.).  We were staying at the Golden Tower hotel in Florence, within walking distance of Enoteca Pinchiorri.  The wives took a cab because they were concerned that the cobblestoned streets would ruin their heels.  With no such concerns, the men took a lively walk through the buzzing Florentine streets to the restaurant.  When we arrived the cab riders were already seated in a reception area surrounded by an armada of Pinchiorri staff waiting to fulfill their every wish.  We were ushered into the reception area and given glasses of Spumante Anna Maria Clemente Rose 2003 from Ca' del Bosco.

We were asked if we wanted to take a tour of the wine cellar.  I had only met the other members of the tour 30 minutes previously in the hotel lobby but, given our shared interests, we were well on our way to becoming fast friends.  Anyway, we all said "yes" and so began a magical journey through the wine drinker's equivalent of Disneyland.  The cellar was intimidatingly large and intimidatingly equipped.  We walked up and down row upon row of the world's finest wines, some dating as far back as 1906, in a variety of formats and with significant vintage depth.  I kept snapping picture after picture and "eyeballing" every nook and cranny in order to ensure that I did not miss any hidden gems.

 As we walked down the aisles, the sommelier would stop from time to time to point out a specific wine or to pass along a pertinent factoid.  In this way we learned that 55,000 bottles were stored in the cellar and 90,000 bottles were stored on floors above the restaurant.  We were also told that the restaurant's wines were valued at €15 million.

At the conclusion of the tour we ascended the stairs to the main level and were ushered into the room where our dinner would be served.  I should note that all along the way we were accompanied by a number of immaculately attired Pinchiorri staff, so much so that at times we had the feeling that we were outnumbered by staff.  Our (private) dining room contained a large, oval-shaped dining table and a manned wine station.  The table was covered with a flowing white tablecloth upon which sat a number of vases which held fresh white flowers.  The captain and wine steward were assigned to us for the evening and courses were brought in by teams of waiters who worked in perfectly choreographed rhythm.  The atmospherics felt right; this was going to be a great experience.

We were formally welcomed by our Captain who also took the opportunity to inform us as to how the dinner would proceed.  It was a tasting menu with an explanation of each course provided once the plates from the prior course were cleared.

The dinner began with two amouse bouches and then we settled in for the remaining eight courses.

For us it was delight after delight. The food was excellent and the wines were equally formidable.

A tartare amberjack with citrus fruit, onion petals marinated in beetroot juice; saffron rice

Sea bass gratinated with capers; artichokes with marjoram and crustacean sauce

Lobster gratinated with pistachios; "cecina" (traditional tart made with chick-pea flour), chick-pea and yogurt sauce

Tagliolini (hand-made long pasta) with baby squids, sage, and potato sauce with lemon scent

Cavatelli in a peas cream with bacalà slices and sausage in red wine sauce

Baby pork from Mora Romagnola with roasted potato purée

A selection of Italian cheeses




and a dessert in three acts:  Hazelnut tart; lemon and basil sherbet;  and passion fruit drops and wild fennel yogurt.

The wines were a Richiari 2009 Poggio Scalette, a Chianti Classico Rancia 2007 Fattoria di Felsina, a Messorio 2003 Le Macchiole, a Barolo Percristina 2001 Clerico, and a Luce 1993 Frescobaldi.

During the course of the meal, our table was visited by both Giorgi and Anne.  At the conclusion of the dinner, we repaired to the smoking room and lit up some Romeo and Juliettas and accompanied them with a 20-year-old Italian brandy.

Team with Giorgi Pinchiorri (center)

This was a great start to our trip.