Monday, June 23, 2014

Extended-bottle-aging versus easy-drinking wines: Winemaking contrasts

At the broadest level, red wine can be described as either: (i) easy-drinking or (ii) styled for extended bottle aging. While the definition of the second class is fully described, the first is not. Mary Gorman-McAdams MW says that easy-drinking wines are viewed as “having broad appeal, especially to novice and marginal drinkers .. are straightforward, fairly simple, inexpensive, and most likely fruity ...” (Wine Words: Easy Drinking, www.thekitchn.com). To that I would add that these wines are generally consumed within a short time of purchase. I will contrast the winemaking decisions made in a number of different areas during the construction of these two wine styles.
Picking Decision

The winemaker will pick at optimal ripeness but the definition will differ between these two styles. For the easy-drinking wine, where fruitiness is a key characteristic, ºBrix may be the only metric and once a target level is attained, picking may commence. Given the urge to produce these wines as inexpensively as possible, every day on the vine is an additional day of weather risk in a low-margin environment. 

For the extended-bottle-aging wine, the stuffing for the develpment of the wine in bottle has to be sourced from the vine. The decision on optimal ripeness will cover a number of objective (sugar, acid, pH, ratio between sugar and acid) and subjective (color, ease of removal of berries from pedicel, texture, aroma, flavor) criteria. Phenolic ripeness is critical in this environment as its components are key enablers of bottle aging and the associated customer appreciation.

Once the decision has been made to harvest, the question then becomes how to implement. The choices are manual (more selective and thorough, less damaging to the grapes -- Boulton et al., Principles and Practices of Winemaking) and machine (faster, more economical, less prone to error, allows work at night -- Boulton et al.) harvesting. In the case of extended-bottle-aging wines, the majority of these grapes are picked by hand to minimize damage as well as to provide a first-level of selection in the field. These grapes are placed in small containers (to minimize crushing pressures) and then transported to the winery as quickly as possible. In many cases, the grapes for the easy drinking wines are machine harvested. It is obviously much more expensive to manual-harvest with in-field selection than it is to machine-harvest but the mantra in that space is that high-quality grapes are a requirement for high-quality wines.

For premium (used interchangeably with extended-bottle-aging herein) wines, grapes are generally picked by lot, fermented in that manner and then blended either after fermentation or after aging. Easy drinking wines are generally picked en masse and any blends would be of the field or fermentation tank variety.

Harvest Reception

Manual Sorting is another level of quality selection that is employed in the construction of high-quality wines and brings with it an associated cost. Manual sorting is not generally employed in the construct of easy-drinking wines.

Fermentation Management

According to Jackson (Wine Science: Principles and Applications), maceration is one of the primary areas in which winemakers can differentiate their wines. In the case of wines for early consumption, the must is generally pressed after 5 days (Jackson) which allows good extraction from the skin (color and enough tannins to ensure its stability) while avoiding the harsh tannins resident in the seeds. The lack of harsh tannins allow these wines to be approachable earlier. Extended-bottle-aging wines are generally macerated for longer periods (up to 3 weeks +) and thus gain the benefits of the “high molecular weight tannins” which polymerize and precipitate out in the bottle. These tannins soften up over time, while aromas and flavors develop, thus providing the user with a benefit for the investment in time (and money).

The size of the fermentation vessel is also differentiated depending on the style of wine being pursued. According to Jackson, premium wines tend to be fermented in 50 - 100-hl vessels which seem to “provide an appropriate balance between economics and ease of operation and the desire to maintain wine individuality.” For the standard wines the practice is to employ fewer but larger (200 to 2000 hl) tanks (Jackson).

Jackson also mentions the use of rotary fermentors which, due to their horizontal deployment and spirally shaped paddles, keep the juice in constant contact with the pomade, thus allowing rapid extraction of anthocyanin and flavors. With the needed elements extracted, the must can be pressed before the heavier phenolics are extracted, making the resultant wine much more approachable.

Yeasts also provide another area of differentiation between the two wine styles. Early-drinking wines will always be inoculated and will use fast-fermenting yeasts with fruity characteristics. Efficiency is the driver here. Extended-bottle-aging wines will, in some cases, use natural yeasts for fermentation as they pursue additional complexity. In the cases where inoculation is practiced, the characteristics pursued would be varietal enhancement and increased flavor complexity.

Pressing

Henderson (http://www.santarosa.edu/~jhenderson/Red%20Crush.pdf) identifies four “times to press” depending on stylistic preferences:
  • When the wine still has residual sugar -- good for young fruity style wines, light character, usually 2 - 5ºBrix
  • As soon as dryness occurs -- good for medium- to full-bodied reds
  • Several days after dryness -- additional flavor extraction
  • Extended maceration -- 1 to 6 weeks after dryness. Cap sinks and harsh tannins settle out, making for a softer wine.
In the case of the easy drinking wine, the second of the four methods is the one most likely to be employed (based both on stylistic and economic considerations --additional flavor not a requirement and the fermenter needed for additional work). The extended-bottle-aging wine would employ either method 3 or 4 in its hunt for additional complexity.

Malolactic Fermentation (MLF)

In practice, most red wines undergo MLF. The process is encouraged (Bauer and Dicks, Control of Malolactic Fermentation in Wine, S. Afr. J. Enol. Vitic. 25(2), 2004): in cooler areas where grapes have high malic acid content; in cases where the wine is aged in oak barrels; and when the wine style calls for long-term aging in bottle. The practice is sometimes forsworn in warmer, lower-acid areas and in the cases where undesirable organoleptic changes or the production of biogenic amines result.The main effects of MLF on wine are (i) a reduction in titratable acidity (by 0.1 to 0.3%) and an increase in pH (0.15 to 0.30). In addition, dramatic organoleptic changes to the wine are evidenced (Lonvaud-Funel, Microbiology of the Malolactic Fermentation: Molecular Aspects, FEMS Microbiology Letters):
  • The specific taste of malic acid disappears
  • Sugars are catabolized to produce mainly lactic and acetic acid
  • Citric acid is transformed into acetic acid and carbonyl compounds, notably the butter-flavored diacetyl
  • Wine taste and color are modified due to the metabolic activity of bacteria on phenolic compounds (tannins, anthocyannins).
Easy-drinking red wines would not materially benefit from the organoleptic changes resulting from MLF. The goal in the vase of these wines are to carry the fruity flavors to the market at the lowest possible cost and in the shortest time possible. However, if appropriate steps are not taken to inhibit the lactic acid bacteria, in-bottle-MLF could result.

Aging

Easy-drinking wines do not benefit from maturation in the cellar and, as such, are not normally subjected to the maturing practices (oak barrels, multiple rackings, etc.) afforded extended-bottle-aging wines. Some of the oak flavor characteristics that accrue as a result of barrel aging can be imparted to easy-drinking wines by introducing oak chips, planks, or extracts into the tanks during alcoholic fermentation.

Premium wines are generally aged in oak (new French, for the most part, with the % new dependent on the winemaker’s style) for extended periods (1 to two years before bottling and for some period post-bottling) resulting in (Dharmadhikari): a replacement of the bright red colors of the young wine by its polymeric form; reduction in grapey aroma and increase in pleasing aromas and flavors; and reduction of astringent and harsh tastes, increasingly replaced by smoother, rounder tastes. According to Jackson, the expense and effort of aging in oak is justified by the additional flavor and complexity gained.

Some premium wines are aged in bottle prior to market release in order to take advantage of reductive changes to tannins (softer), acid (softer), and flavor compounds (increased complexity). Easy drinking wines are not so treated.

Blending

Wine blends are constructs of two or more varietals, and/or micro/macro-climates, and or clones, and/or juice types (press or free-run) that are implemented by the winemaker to, among other reasons, overcome wine deficiencies or defects, improve balance, or enhance complexity. As regards the structural components (structure, texture, flavor), Dr. Zoecklein (Components of Red Wine Mouthfeel)argues that a balanced relationship must exist between the tastes of sweetness, on the one hand, and acid, astringency and bitterness on the other, in order to yield the perception of a quality wine to the taster.  The preferred relationship is captured in his Palate Balance Equation:

         Sweet ⇄ Acid + Phenolics (Astringency and Bitterness),

where

          Sweet = Carbohydrates + Polysaccharides + Ethanol,
          Acid = Population of organic acids, and
          Phenolics = Skin, seed, and stem phenols + barrel phenols + enological tannins + volatile    phenols.

According to classof1855.com, complexity in wine is demonstrated by "multiple layers and nuances of bouquet and flavors that are formed mostly in mature wines because aging contributes to this attribute." Further, "complexity creates interest and often unfolds layer upon layer on the nose and in the mouth if the wine is at its peak. Compared to complex wines, other wines seem shallow or one-dimensional."

Easy-drinking wines are in pursuit of neither complexity or balance and so do not actively pursue these elements where blending is practiced. Blending in easy drinking wines would tend to be more blends of convenience rather than pursuit of higher quality ideals. Field blends and co-fermentations would be the order of the day, for the most part. In the case of blending extended bottle-aging wines, the lots are generally fermented and aged separately and then blended prior to bottling in a fairly extended process which may utilize multiple individuals on a blending team.

Finishing/Bottling

If the wine is made to be drunk within a year, metatartic acid can be used as an inexpensive means of establishing short-term tartrate stability (Jackson). Metatartaric acid works by restricting potassium bitartrate crystalization and interfering with the growth of calcium tartrate crystals (Jackson). This treatment is only effective for about 1 year, however, as metatartaric slowly hydrolyzes back to tartaric acid.

Given enough time, racking and fining can produce stable, crystal clear wines (Jackson). The early bottling associated with easy-drinking wines does not provide enough time for these two practices to fully clarify the wine so other procedures (such as centrifugation and filtration) have to be employed in order to realize the necessary clarity.

Filtration is avoided by many premium winemakers because of a fear of flavor-stripping.

Screw Caps are very effective as a closure choice but their usage to date has been primarily in the easy-drinking market due to "stigma" issues as well as some concern that the reductive environment they support does not promote favorable conditions for extended-bottle-aging. Synthetic stoppers have issues with oxygen ingress but are acceptable for wines that will be drunk early.

Bag-in-box containers protect wines from oxidation for 9 months or longer and are a viable container for easy-drinking wines. These containers have some stigma issues to overcome, however, and have not been used as premium wine containers.


©Wine -- Mise en abyme

Thursday, June 12, 2014

Monitoring the malolactic fermentation of wine

I have recently described the malolactic fermentation process. In general, a winemaker needs to be able to tell if/when MLF has commenced, how it is proceeding, if any problems are in the offing, and when it has concluded. Key to addressing these concerns are the establishment of benchmarks for the beginning and end of MLF and a regime for tracking its progress. 

According to Boulton et al. (Principles and Practices of Winemaking, Chapman and Hall, 1996), there is a difference in perception as to what constitutes the MLF duration depending on whether you are a microbiologist or a winemaker. The microbiologist sees MLF as commencing with the “introduction of viable bacteria into the wine or must” and ending “when the bacteria have gone through the growth phase and have re-entered their final resting or stationary phase.” The winemaker, on the other hand, will equate the start of fermentation with a noticeable drop in malic acid levels (grape juice contains between 1 and 8 g/l malic acid) and as completed when the malic acid has finally disappeared (vintessential.com.au (Malolactic Fermentation Monitoring -- Resources for Winemakers) recommends a figure of < 0.05 g/l as safe for declaring the end of MLF while Katherine Mansfield (Monitoring Malolactic Fermentation 3 Ways, Cornell University College of Agriculture and Life Sciences, Cornell Cooperative Extension) cites a number of 30 mg/l).

Even though acknowledging the microbiologists' view of MLF duration, Boulton et al. accept the winemakers perspective in that they see the “measurement of the disappearance of malic acid as the accepted means for determining whether the malolactic fermentation has occurred.” Lerm et al., place this measurement of the presence of malic acid within a broader context: “The continuous monitoring of MLF is essential and often neglected by winemakers.” Continuous monitoring “allows the winemaker to follow the progress of malic acid degradation as well as the bacteria responsible for the fermentation. This is also a way for the winemaker to identify any difficulties before they can affect the quality of the wine.”

There are a number of tools that are available for the monitoring of MLF and they are summarized in the table below. 

Selected MLF Monitoring Techniques and their Attributes
Monitoring Technique
Advantages
Disadvantages
Paper Chromatography (PC)
  • separate compounds based on their polarity
  • visually follow disappearance of malic acid
  • commonly used in winery


  • easy to use
  • simple, affordable and indicative of MLF progress


  • strictly qualitative so still need quantitative values to verify MLF completion
  • not precise
  • not specific for L-malic acid
Thin Layer Chromatography (TLC)
- similar to PC but uses TLC plates instead of paper


  • easy to use
  • simple and affordable
  • results in one hour,; much faster than PC


  • not precise
  • not specific for L-malic acid
  • strictly qualitative so still need quantitative values to verify MLF completion
Reflectance
  • Reflectoquant®
  • based on reflectance photometry
  • use reactive test strips to analyze for various wine components

  • a fraction of the cost of a spectrophotometer
  • half the cost of an enzymatic kit
  • measure multiple wine parameters
  • fastest method currently available (5 min/sample)
  • relative accuracy of 10%

  • measure relative malic acid levels so still need to qualify absolute levels
  • operating range 1 to 60 mg/L, so some samples need to be diluted or decolorised
  • need to be calibrated with reference method
Enzymatic Analysis
  • uses enzyme that specifically react with L-malic acid then use UV-visible spectrometer to monitor enzymatic reaction
  • most commonly used method
  • MLF complete if malic acid is less than 200 to 300 mg/l

  • quantitative
  • excellent precision
  • kits readily available
  • quantify very low levels of malic acid
  • results in 30 minutes

  • more complex
  • more expensive
  • short shelf life of reagents after activation
  • require use of accurate micro-pipettes
  • turbid samples need to be centrifuged
Capillary Electrophoresis (CE)


  • highly accurate
  • short analysis time; fast results


  • extremely expensive
  • not recommended for everyday use in winery
Fourier-transform Infrared (FT-IR) Spectroscopy
- use infrared spectra to quantify wine parameters


  • accurate
  • small sample volume
  • short analysis time, fast results



  • expensive equipment
  • accuracy dependent on reference values and calibration curve
High Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC)
- separation of compounds based on polarity and interaction with stationary or solid phase



- highly accurate


  • extremely expensive
  • not recommended for everyday use in winery
Source: Lerm et al., Table 7.

Of the mechanisms listed above, the one that is most commonly used in wineries today is paper chromatography. Paper chromatography detects the presence of malic acid but does not tell its concentration. As such, it should never be used to make a decision regarding the end of MLF. According to Mansfield, the lower level of malic acid detection for paper chromatography is 100 mg/L, way above the 30 mg/L considered by her lab to be the “safe number” for the end of MLF. The risk associated with prematurely calling the end of MLF is residual malic acid which can be metabolized by latent LAB in the bottle with a host of resultant problems (change in color, aroma, flavor; CO₂ production; clouding (Lisa Van de Water, Monitoring microbes during cellaring/bottling, practicalwinery.com, January/February 2010)). In a table accompanying the article, the author shows that Oenococcus would be found at levels of 500+/ml if residual malic acid were present. Ms. Van de Water suggests checking wines during MLF for the presence of spoilage bacteria and doing so by microscope as well as by PCR.

A robust MLF monitoring protocol which incorporates some of the tools listed in the table above is as follows:
  1. Take representative samples of cellar barrels for testing. Care should be taken to ensure that ease of access does not determine the barrels utilized for sampling.
  2. Test consistently.  I propose that the sampling be conducted every two weeks or at topping.
  3. Position paper chromatography as a tool in the MLF monitoring toolbox for measuring progress. Paper chromatography detects the presence of malic acid but does not tell the concentration. The level of malic acid in the wine needs to be below 30 mg/L in order for the microbial stability benefits of the MLF process to accrue. 
  4. Utilize enzymatic analysis in the MLF monitoring protocol as a means of certifying the end of MLF. As the cost of the equipment for enzymatic tests are very high, I recommend the services of an outside lab for this purpose. As recommended by vintessential.com.au, the costs of these outside tests can be minimized by submitting barrel composites. If no malic acid is detected, then all of the barrels will be assumed to have completed MLF. If the test comes back positive, then the barrels would be tested individually in order to identify the offending barrel(s).
  5. Include the human factors (nose, palate, and skills; Dr Wann, Power Point presentation) in the MLF monitoring process. Dr. Wann recommends: (i) checking for CO₂ evolution; (ii) smelling and tasting the barrel at every topping (heads up on potential spoilage activity); (iii) maintaining an appropriate temperature (between 18 and 22℃); and (iv) to be aware of increasing pH levels (potential foothold for spoilage organisms). In that CO₂ is one of the outputs of the MLF process, its presence is indicative of ongoing malate degradation.
  6. Institute a number of post-MLF processes to ensure the microbial stability of the wines through to the blending and bottling processes. According to Wibowo et al., additions of SO₂ and storing the wine at higher temperatures leads to the progressive loss of viability of any bacteria surviving the MLF. The wines themselves may be sterilized by filtering with membranes having pore sizes of 0.22 to 0.45µm. Lafon-Lafourcade et al., sees the decline in LAB accelerated by increasing temperatures, lowering the wine pH, and increasing the alcohol concentration, actions which, it seems, combine to provide a toxic environment for the bacteria. The addition of SO₂ does result in a rapid loss in cell viability, they agree, but growth recommences at a later date. The specific post-MLF operations that should be undertaken, according to Boulton et al. are as follows:
    • Transfer the wines off the lees and a rough filtration
    • Adjustments of temperature and pH and addition of SO₂. The recommendation here is for 0.8 mg/L
    • Fining operations could also be performed at this time
Following this set of procedures will minimize the potential for microbes indicating their presence in the bottle.


©Wine -- Mise en abyme

Tuesday, June 10, 2014

The malolactic fermentation of wine

In recent posts I have discussed malic acid and lactic acid bacteria (LAB), two of the major actors in the malolactic fermentation (MLF) drama. In this post I will elaborate on the arena within which this drama unfolds and how the interaction of malic acid and other minor players with LAB results in lactic acid and other metabolites. Let us begin by defining MLF.

According to Sauvageot and Vivier (Effects of Malolactic Fermentation on Sensory Properties of Four Burgundy Wines, AJEV 48(2), 1997), MLF is a bacterial conversion -- most commonly performed by Leuconostoc strains due to their tolerance of the high acid and alcohol content associated with wine -- of L-malic acid to L-lactic acid and CO₂. The MLF process can be represented thusly (Lerm et al., Malolactic Fermentation: The ABCs of MLF, S. Afr. J. Enol. Vitic. 31(2), 2010):

L-malic acid  + LAB  →    L-lactic acid          + CO₂
(dicarboxylic)                  (monocarboxylic)

wherein a carboxyl group (C(O)OH) is removed from the dicarboxylic L-malic acid. The reaction is catalyzed by the LAB along one of three pathways (Lerm et al., Bauer and Dicks, Control of Malolactic Fermentation in Wine: A Review, S. Afr. J. Enol. Vitic. 25(2), 2004):
  1. Direct conversion of malic acid to lactic acid via malate decarboxylase (the preferred pathway for wine LAB)
  2. L.casei and Enterococcus faecales possess a malic enzyme that converts L-malic to pyruvic acid which is in turn reduced to lactic acid by L-lactate dehydrogenase
  3. Via L. fermentum,  malate is reduced by malate dehydrogenase to oxaloacetate, followed by decarboxylation to pyruvate which is further reduced to lactic acid.
The main effects of MLF on wine are (i) a reduction in titratable acidity (by 0.1 to 0.3%) and an increase in pH (0.15 to 0.30). In addition, dramatic organoleptic changes to the wine are evidenced (Lonvaud-Funel, Microbiology of the Malolactic Fermentation: Molecular Aspects, FEMS Microbiology Letters):
  • The specific taste of malic acid disappears
  • Sugars are catabolized to produce mainly lactic and acetic acid
  • Citric acid is transformed into acetic acid and carbonyl compounds, notably the butter-flavored diacetyl
  • Wine taste and color are modified due to the metabolic activity of bacteria on phenolic compounds (tannins, anthocyannins).
By synthesizing anti-bacterial compounds and depriving the wine of nutrients, MLF also contributes to its microbial stability (Lonvaud-Funel).

In practice, most red wines, and selected white wines, undergo MLF. The process is encouraged (Bauer and Dicks, Control of Malolactic Fermentation in Wine, S. Afr. J. Enol. Vitic. 25(2), 2004): in cooler areas where grapes have high malic acid content; in cases where the wine is aged in oak barrels; and when the wine style calls for long-term aging in bottle. The practice is sometimes forsworn in warmer, lower-acid areas and in the cases where undesirable organoleptic changes or the production of biogenic amines result.

MLF is initiated either naturally or through inoculation of the wine with an LAB strain. In the case of indigenous initiation, upon the completion of alcoholic fermentation, and following a lag phase, the surviving LAB begin to multiply rapidly. MLF begins when their numbers approach 106 cells/ml (Savageot and Vivier; Wibowo et al.; Lonvaud-Funel; Lerm et al.). Lafon-Lafourcade et al., posit that this growth originates from winery equipment which serve as incubators for the LAB. Oenococcus. oeni is the main species that develops here but Lactobacillus and Pediococcus spp. may proliferate and conduct the MLF if the wine pH approaches 4.0. If MLF is not desired, clarification of must or newly fermented wine will remove the majority of the LAB and, if excessive, its potential nutrient sources, and reduce the possibility of indigenous inoculation (Wibowo et al.). In addition, wines that have undergone thermovinification (rapid heating of the must to near boiling point in order to extract anthocyanins and tannins) are less susceptible to MLF (Wibowo et al.).

During the time between the end of AF and the initiation of MLF, no SO₂ can be applied to the wine because of its toxic effect on the LAB. During this time, then, the wine is exposed to the potential of oxidation and attack by spoilage organisms. The use of starter cultures reduces this risk by shortening the time between the end of AF and the initiation of MLF and by ensuring a rapid onset of MLF with a very high population of viable bacteria (on the order of 1011 cells/g, according to Lerm et al.). Given the environment within which the LAB has to operate, a starter culture should have the following characteristics (Lerm et al.):
  • Tolerance to low pH, high ethanol, and SO₂
  • Good growth characteristics under winemaking conditions
  • Compatibility with the S. cerevisiae strain(s) being used for alcoholic fermentation
  • Ability to survive the production environment
  • Does not produce biogenic amines
  • Does not produce off-flavors or off-odors
  • Production of aroma compounds that will favorably impact the wine’s aroma profile.
There are a number of factors that affect the development of LAB and, as a result, the activation and effectiveness of MLF. For example, wine pH affects (Wibowo et al.):
  • LAB growth rate
  • The LAB species that proliferate
  • The metabolic behavior of the species that grow
  • The survival of LAB.
Temperature is synergistic with ethanol levels as it relates to inhibiting LAB (Lerm et al.):
  • The optimal growth temperature of LAB decreases at high ethanol concentrations
  • Elevated temperatures lower the ability of LAB to withstand increased ethanol concentration
  • Temperatures of 25℃ and above, combined with ethanol levels of 10 -14%, almost completely inhibits LAB growth.
A listing of the factors beyond pH and temperature that affect LAB growth and development are provided in the tables below.


TABLE 1. The influence of different winemaking practices on LAB growth
Practice
Influence
Degree of must clarification
Significant impact on bacterial growth. Yeast produce more medium chain fatty acids in highly clarified must
Skin contact prior to AF
Direct effect on extraction of nitrogenous and other macromolecules stimulate LAB growth and malolactic activity
Choice of yeast strain
Inhibitory and stimulatory effects differ between strains
Aging of wine on yeast lees
Yeast autolysis release nutrients that stimulate LAB growth and malolactic activity
Source: Lerm et al., TABLE 2

TABLE 2. Yeast activity inhibiting LAB via the production of yeast metabolites
Yeast Metabolite
Effect on LAB and/or MLF
Ethanol
Affects growth ability
SO2
AF with SO2 producing yeast strain results in wine inhibitory to MLF
Medium chain fatty acids
Affect LAB growth and reduce ability to metabolise malic acid. Combination of fatty acids (hexanoic, octanoic and decanoic acid) cause greater inhibition than individual compounds.
Metabolites of protein nature
Peptide produced by S. cerevisiae during AF: inhibit O. oeni by disruption of cell membrane; inhibition dependent on SO2
Source: Lerm et al., TABLE 3

According to Boulton et al. (Principles and Practices of Winemaking, Chapman and Hall, 1996), there is a difference in perception as to what constitutes the MLF period, depending on whether you are a microbiologist or a winemaker. The microbiologist measures the MLF from the “introduction of viable bacteria into the wine or must” and it ends “when the bacteria have gone through the growth phase and have re-entered their final resting or stationary phase.” The winemaker, on the other hand, will equate the start of fermentation with a noticeable drop in malic acid levels (grape juice contains between 1 and 8 g/l malic acid) and as completed when the malic acid has finally disappeared (vintessential.com.au (Malolactic Fermentation Monitoring -- Resources for Winemakers) recommends a figure of < 0.05 g/l as safe for declaring the end of MLF while Katherine Mansfield (Monitoring Malolactic Fermentation 3 Ways, Cornell Cooperative Extension) cites the number 30 g/ml. That discrepancy in the metric notwithstanding, Boulton et al., see the “measurement of the disappearance of malic acid as the accepted means for determining whether the malolactic fermentation has occurred.”

Measurement of the degradation of malic acid is one of the key aspects of monitoring MLF, the topic of my next post


©Wine -- Mise en abyme

Sunday, June 1, 2014

Lactic acid bacteria: Pre-, intra-, and post-malolactic-fermentation development

Either concurrent with, or post-alcoholic-fermentation, a number of wines are subjected to a process --malolactic fermentation (MLF) -- wherein the harder malic acid is converted to lactic acid by lactic acid bacteria (LAB). The perceived benefits of this process to the final wine are:
  • Deacidification, with a resultant increase in pH
  • Increased microbial stability through removal of malic acid as a possible carbon substrate; and
  • Modification of the wine's aroma profile.
I described the origin and evolution of malic acid in my most recent post and provide a similar treatment of LAB in the current.

The genera from which the LABs are drawn are shown below. The species associated with wine are (Wibowo et al., AJEV, 36 (4) 1988):
  • Oenococcus.oeni -- mainly during MLF
  • Pediococcus cerevisiae -- mostly after MLF; predominantly in wines with high pH
  • Pediococcus pentosaceous -- mostly after MLF; predominantly in wines with high pH
  • Lactobacillus spp. -- mainly after MLF.


Phylogenetic trees of Lactobacillales constructed on the
basis of concatenated alignments of ribosomal proteins
Source: pnas.org

Doctor Murli Dahrmadikari (Lactic Acid Bacteria and Wine Spoilage, extension.iastate.edu) describes LAB thusly:
These organisms are gram positive, catalase negative, nonsporing cocci, coccobacilli or rods. They are microaerophilic (sic) that means that they grow well under conditions of low oxygen content. Since they can grow under low oxygen conditions, they can grow throughout the wine (as opposed to on the surface of the wine) even though the container is kept full. The bacteria can metabolize sugars, acids and other constituents in wine and produce several compounds. Some of these are undesirable and constitute spoilage.
LAB utilize two pathways for the metabolism of glucose and a third for the metabolism of pentose (Lerm et al., Malolactic Fermentation: The ABCs of MLF, S. Afr. J. Enol. Vitic. 31 (2), 2010). One of the glucose pathways (EMP) converts glucose into pyruvate over a number of steps and then into lactic acid. In this process, 1 mole of glucose yields 2 moles of lactic acid plus 2 ATPs. This process is called homolactic fermentation and all Pediococcus species utilize this mechanism. The second glucose pathway (6-PG/PK) yields lactic acid, carbon dioxide, ethanol, acetate, and 1 ATP. The bacteria utilizing this pathway are called heterolactic fermenters and this includes all strains of Leuconstoc, some Lactobacillus strains and Oenococcus.oeni. The pentose pathway combines pentose with a phosphate derivative before coalescing with the later portions of the 6-PG/Pk pathway for completion. The outputs of the pentose pathway are lactic acid, acetic acid, and carbon dioxide.

The LAB in wine originate from grape and grape leaves and are brought into the winery at harvest (Dharmadhikari; Lerm et al.; Wibowo et al.). The LAB diversity and population density are limited by  grape maturity and sanitary conditions and levels are generally on the order of 100 cells/gm (Wibowo et al.) The species that are present at this time include Pediococcus and Leuconstoc (Lerm et al.).

Once the grapes are brought into the winery, the LAB population increases dramatically, implicating the winery environment in this proliferation. According to Lerm et al., the population rises to 103 - 104 cells per ml shortly after crushing and prior to alcoholic fermentation (AF). In a study of the evolution of LAB, Lafon-Lafourcade et al. (Occurrence of Lactic Acid Bacteria During the Different Stages of Vinification and Conservation of Wines, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 1983, 46 (4)) show populations of 104 cells/ml at 14℃ and 19℃ if (i) unsulfited and (ii) sulfited at 50 mg/l. At 100 mg/l of SO2, however, the LAB population declines 10-fold. The LAB species present at this stage are L. plantarium, L. casei, Leuconstoc mesenteries, P. damnosus, and, to a lesser extent, O. oeni (Lerm et al.).

During the course of AF, the LAB population levels fall precipitously with only 200 cells/ml surviving the process (Wibowo et al.; Lafon-Lafourcade et al.). Wibowo et al., attribute this decline to ethanol sensitivity. The only LAB strain that survives AF is O. Oeni.

AF is followed by a lag phase which is, in turn, followed by rapid proliferation of LAB with levels rising to between 106 - 1010 prior to MLF. Lafon-Lafourcade et al., posit that this growth originates from winery equipment which serve as incubators for the LAB that would perform a natural inoculation of MLF. O. oeni is the main species that develops here but Lactobacillus and Pediococcus spp. may proliferate and conduct the MLF if the wine pH approaches 4.0.

There are a number of factors that affect the development of LAB and, as a result, the activation and effectiveness of MLF. For example, wine pH affects (Wibowo et al.):
  • LAB growth rate
  • The LAB species that proliferate
  • The metabolic behavior of the species that grow
  • The survival of LAB.

A listing of the factors beyond pH that affect LAB growth and development are provided in Tables 1 and 2 below.

TABLE 1. The influence of different winemaking practices on LAB growth
Practice
Influence
Degree of must clarification
Significant impact on bacterial growth. Yeast produce more medium chain fatty acids in highly clarified must
Skin contact prior to AF
Direct effect on extraction of nitrogenous and other macromolecules stimulate LAB growth and malolactic activity
Choice of yeast strain
Inhibitory and stimulatory effects differ between strains
Aging of wine on yeast lees
Yeast autolysis release nutrients that stimulate LAB growth and malolactic activity
Source: Lerm et al., TABLE 2


TABLE 2. Yeast activity inhibiting LAB via the production of yeast metabolites
Yeast Metabolite
Effect on LAB and/or MLF
Ethanol
Affects growth ability
SO2
AF with SO2 producing yeast strain results in wine inhibitory to MLF
Medium chain fatty acids
Affect LAB growth and reduce ability to metabolise malic acid. Combination of fatty acids (hexanoic, octanoic and decanoic acid) cause greater inhibition than individual compounds.
Metabolites of protein nature
Peptide produced by S. cerevisiae during AF: inhibit O. oeni by disruption of cell membrane; inhibition dependent on SO2
Source: Lerm et al., TABLE 3

According to Wibowo et al., additions of sulfur dioxide, and storing the wine at higher temperatures, leads to the progressive loss of viability of any LAB surviving MLF. According to Lafon-Lafourcade et al., under standard conditions, the surviving LAB remained viable post-MLF, exhibiting, initially, a tendency for further growth and then showing a slow, progressive decline over a 200-day storage period. At temperatures over 20℃, a rapid decline in viability was recorded and at 26℃, no LAB activity was recorded after 80 days. Lafon-Lafourcade et al. found that the decline in LAB viability was accelerated by increasing temperature, lowering the wine pH, and increasing the alcohol concentration. These actions, it seems, combine to provide a toxic environment for the bacteria. Addition of sulfur dioxide, they agree, does result in a rapid loss in cell viability but growth recommences at a later date.

At the end of barrel aging, the wine microbial population is stabilized but its population prior to bottling is 103 - 104 cells/ml, if unfiltered, with microbes such as Acetobacter, S. cerevisiae, and O. oeni predominant (Renouf et al., Survival of Wine Microorganisms in the Bottle during Storage, AJEV 58(3), 2007). Filtering with a 0.4 micron filter sheet will eliminate all bacteria from the wine.

Now that the two most important players in the MLF drama have been described, I will cover the MLF process itself when I revisit this topic.

©Wine -- Mise en abyme

Thursday, May 29, 2014

Malic acid: Preparation for malolactic fermentation

Malolactic fermentation (MLF) has been practiced by winemakers for many a year but the benefits have not always been widely acclaimed. But, as Jackson (Wine Science: Principles and Applications, 3rd ed., Elsevier, 2008) notes, the controversy seems to be over and it is now generally accepted that the process can impact wines as follows (Lerm et al., Malolactic Fermentation: The ABCs of MLF, S. Afr. J. Enol. Vitic., 31 (2), 2010):
  • Deacidification, with a resultant increase in pH
  • Contribute to the microbial stability through removal of malic acid as a possible carbon substrate; and
  • Modification of the wine's aroma profile.
In its simplest terms, MLF is the conversion of the "hard" malic acids into the softer lactic acid by lactic acid bacteria (LAB). But what is the origin of the malic acid so unceremoniously neutered? And what was the path that it trod to get here? I explore these questions in this post.

As shown in the figure below, malate makes its first appearance in the grape berry in Stage I of its development. Malic acid is produced in the berry by one of two processes: (i) Fixation of carbon dioxide by PEP carboxylase (an enzyme that catalyzes the addition of bicarbonate to PEP to form oxaloacetate and inorganic phosphate) and (ii) synthesis from sugars via glycolysis and the Tricarboxylic acid cycle (TCA). The oxaloacetic acid produced in the PEPC process is reduced to malate by the enzyme malate dehydrogenase (MDH)

Grape berry development (Source:www.extension.org)

It is estimated that tartaric and malic acids constitute between 70% and 90% of total berry acid content, with malic acid's contribution on the order of 23% - 40%. Malic acid concentration increases constantly in the first stage of development, increases sharply in Stage II, and then declines rapidly in Stage III. Prior to véraison, malic  acid levels are the highest of any of the organic acids in the berry, reaching levels of up to 25 g/L, with a resultant pH of 2.5. Pre- and post-véraison occurrences, however, contribute to a significant reduction in malic acid levels (Straus et al., Malic Acid in Wine, S. Afr. J. Enol. Vitic., 27 (2), 2006):
  • Malic acid in the berry vacuoles are diluted by water influx in Stage II
  • There is a significant decrease in L-malic acid biosynthesis post-véraison
    • The slowing of glycolytic carbon flow during véraison results in increased glucose and fructose in the berry vacuole and a decrease in malic acid synthesis via pyruvic acid in the TCA cycle
    • The biosynthesis of malic acid via the PEPC cycle is reduced due to véraison-induced lack of PEPC transcription 
  • During véraison, chlorophyll is degraded so the berry shifts its metabolism from sucrose respiration to malic acid respiration.
As a result of the pre- and post-véraison retrenchments, malic acid concentration will decline to between 4 and 6.5 g/l; in some cases, getting down to 1 g/l.

A point of note is the role that malic acid plays in the development of flavor and color compounds in the berry. While the berry turns its attention to its reproductive phase -- and directs the attention of its sugars to plumping and sweetening the berry --  it fails to utilize those energy sources for the development of the compounds that are so important for wine quality. But, as I have mentioned previously, the berry is not interested in producing great wines; it is interested in genetic survival. Malic acid, then, is respired to meet the berry's energy needs for development of the flavor and color compounds.

Of the three reasons listed for malolactic fermentation, two would seem to be intrinsically related to malic acid: de-acidification and substrate for microbial instability. And de-acidification would only seem to be appropriate in the cooler-climate regions. In the warmer regions, where low acidity and high pH are already an issue, the downsides associated with the pursuit of malolactic fermentation has to be significantly outweighed by the aroma-enrichment benefits.

In his study of solutes in grape berries, Coombe (Distribution of Solutes within the Developing Grape Berry in Relation to its Morphology, AJEV, 38 (2), 1987) showed the evolution of malate levels during grape development by measuring its presence at four stages identified thusly:
  1. Close to véraison, berries hard and free; 6.2ºBrix
  2. Berries ripening; 10.2ºBrix
  3. Early ripe stage; 17.4ºBrix
  4. Overripe; 26.4ºBrix
Some of his key findings, re malate, were as follows:
  • Malate was the most abundant solute in the flesh of unripe berries but declined during development by proportions comparable with the degree of increase that occurred in glucose and fructose concentrations
  • The decline in malate was most notable between 10ºBrix and 17ºBrix
  • The levels of malate in the skin and brush showed smaller changes as the berries developed (they were smaller to begin with and declined less over the stages of berry development)
  • The malate decline in the skin occurred earlier in the regions closest to the pedicel
  • Within the flesh, the lowest malate concentrations were found where vascular bundles occur.
Jackson noted that the latter point may result from "malate metabolism initiating around the axial vascular bundles and progressing outwards." Regardless, at maturity, the malic acid levels in the skin may be higher than the levels in the flesh.

The overall regional climate will determine the final berry malate levels. In colder climates, the rate of berry respiration is low and this results in immature grapes at harvest with high total acidity (TA) and low pH (Jackson, Straus et al.). In this situation, malic acid can be as much as 50% of the TA in the grape berry, resulting in a sour tasting wine. In warmer climates, conversely, the rate of malic acid respiration is higher with a resultant low (insufficient) TA and high pH at harvest. Wines made from these grapes can have a flat taste and may be susceptible to microbial spoilage (Jackson). Further, these wines may not age well. Malic acid content is thus a key factor in the determination of optimal harvest date.

According to Straus et al., mature grapes have between 2 and 6.5 g/l at maturity with levels above that only present in grapes harvested after cold summers in the cool-climate viticultural regions of the world. In those cases, the levels could rise to as much as 15 - 16 g/l. And the levels at harvest are, for the most part, the levels in the wine when the decision regarding malolactic fermentation is made. The type of crushing equipment used may have some impact on malic acid levels but that is minimal (Jackson).  Also, according to Jackson, during alcoholic fermentation, the yeasts may increase the wine pH by converting some of the malic acid to lactic acid but this is highly variable by yeast strain and has not been established to any reliable degree.

So, after its many contributions along the way; its sacrifices to keep the berry alive during its most vulnerable time, this is malic acid's reward. A neutering; a sex change operation by some egotistic, self-serving winemaker who wants to make his/her wine softer. Where are your cojones man? Well that is not a question that I can answer. When I next visit this topic I will look at the other player in this drama: the lactic acid bacteria.


©Wine -- Mise en abyme

Tuesday, May 27, 2014

Our road to Burgundy: Stateside steps

Ron and Bev Siegel are easily the most accomplished, endowed, and knowledgeable wine collectors in the Orlando area. They also happen to be exceptionally good friends with whom we spend a lot of time locally as well as at out-of-town food and wine events. So when I received an email from Ron at 12:46 pm on 9/24/13 regarding a trip to Burgundy, with Raj Par as the Shepherd, my terse reply (at 1:17 pm) was "let's do it."

Ron and Bev with Serge Hochar of Chateau Musar

The trip was being offered by an organization called IfOnly (ifOnly.com) which seeks to connect individuals with "luminaries" in the fields of food, wine, golf, etc., in order to realize experiences that "amaze and inspire." The purchasers are exposed to amazing experiences while the "luminary" benefits in that a donation is made to his or her named. The ifOnly descriptor for the Burgundy tour is presented below.


This trip was tailor made for us:
  • Did I mention that Ron is a very serious Burgundy collector with multiple instances of the leading vintages of the leading producers resident in his cellars?
  • Did I mention that while he was in kindergarten and the other kids were learning their ABCs he was learning his DRCs?
  • We drink a lot of "passable" Burgundy. For example,

Missing Link Tasting
Mini-DRC vertical at Bern's Steakhouse
Dinner at the residence of the owner of The Wine Barn
Dinner at Victoria and Albert Chef's Table
Burgundy Tasting at Capital Grille

  • Neither of us had previously visited the Burgundy region
  • We wanted to do so badly but wanted to do it "the right way"
  • The proposed trip -- with its promise of unparalleled access to the leading winemakers in the region and the opportunity to tap into the mind and habits of one of the leading wine experts of our time -- seemed the optimal manner in which to see Burgundy and its potential exceeded even our wildest musings. 

On September 30, Ron informed me that we had secured the booking. On October 1, Katie from ifOnly contacted Ron to let us know that she was going to be meeting with Raj on the following day to get some potential dates for the trip. She did end up speaking with Raj by phone on that same day and the best fit for him was April 30th to May 2nd. I did not even have to look at my calendar to know that I was going to be in Burgundy over those days. This was concrete; everything else was jelly.

The next step was for us to connect with Raj to get a sense of what an agenda would look like.Ron spearheaded this activity and when I checked in with him a few days later to find out what progress had been made, I found out that he had bought a whole heap of Sandhi wines (Raj is the winemaker for the Sandhi label). Hey, I thought you were going to engage him on our trip and instead you come away owning some California wine. You don't even like California wines. This guy needs an intervention. Well at least he had given Raj a listing of the producers that we would like to visit during the course of the trip.

After our year-end round of parties, we began serious planning for the trip. My idea of a plan is something you do two days before you need to be there; Ron's idea is to actually construct an itinerary, make reservations, and get it out of the way. I succumbed. We traded ideas about eating places in Paris and Beaune and settled on two touch points: Le Taillevent in Paris and bistro de l'hotel Beaune in Burgundy.

Ron wanted very much to ensure that we would visit DRC while in Burgundy so was leaving nothing to chance. He tapped every source and contact that he had in an attempt to get an entree and ran up a lot of dead-ends but kept on trying until he finally hit paydirt. We were going to visit DRC as our first appointment in Burgundy on April 30.

On April 10th, Raj emailed to say that Dujac and Rousseau were confirmed. He also indicated that May 1 and 2 were national holidays in France and it was proving difficult to get anyone to commit to meeting with us on this days. On April 19th he emailed us with the final itinerary:

April 30: DRC, Rousseau, and Roulot
May 1st: Carillon
May 2nd: Dujac, Mugneret-GIbourg, Faiveley

In that email he also proposed that we meet for dinner in Beaune on the evening of April 29th. We already had booked dinner for four at bistro de l'Hotel so we added two seats to our reservation in order to make that happen.

One of the issues that we had to work out was how we would travel from Paris to Beaune. I love driving in France so I had gone ahead and booked a van with Europcar. I alerted the team to this and, while Ron was open, the wives were dead set against it. They wanted to take the train. I have traveled with Ron and Bev before and I have seen their luggage. Good luck wrestling with that on a train. The women suggested that we could take smaller suitcases for the Burgundy portion of the trip and leave the larger suitcases with the Paris hotel as we would be returning to spend Saturday in Paris. We punted and said we would make the decision later. In the meantime I held on to my reservation with Euopcar. And my reservation at the little lunch hideaway between Paris and Beaune.

On the morning of April 26th, I headed to Paris by way of Newark while Ron, launching a little later in the day, headed for the same destination via Atlanta.

Burgundy we are on our way.


©Wine -- Mise en abyme

Sunday, May 25, 2014

Potential contributors to "stuck" alcoholic fermentations

In the recent past, I wrote a post on stuck fermentations and identified a number of contributory factors. In this post I expand on a number of those factors. 

Let us begin with some definitions. According to Bisson (Stuck and Sluggish Fermentations, AJEV 50(1) 1999), “Incomplete or stuck enological fermentations are defined as those leaving a higher than desired residual sugar content in the wine at the end of the alcoholic fermentation.” Arrested fermentations are generally the result of conditions in the grape juice that lead to cell death and a concomitant reduction in viable biomass and sugar conversion. Some of the contributors to the aberrant conditions are listed below:
  • High sugar concentration – According to Jackson (Wine Science: Principles and Applications, 3rd edition, Elsevier, New York, 2008), at sugar concentrations in excess of 25 – 30%, the potential for stuck fermentations increases significantly. High sugar content can cause cells to lose water through osmosis and contract, resulting in slow or incomplete fermentation. High sugar content also increases the production of acetic acid and its esters.
  • Nutrient limitation – According to Bisson, lack of macronutrients such as nitrogen and phosphate can lead to stuck fermentations; as will an imbalance of  pH and potassium ions. Adequate levels of nitrogen are required in both the growth and stationary phases. In the stationary phase, it is required as: (i) an energy source, (ii) amino acid for synthesis of actively degraded proteins, and (iii) compounds needed to minimize the inhibitory effects of ethanol. Nitrogen is especially important in the re-synthesis of sugar transporters and the supply must be available early enough to be stored in the cell vacuole rather than have its translocation inhibited by later high ethanol concentrations. According to Allison Crowe (Avoiding Stuck Ferments, Wine Business Monthly, August 2007), macronutrients, micronutrients, and long chain fatty acids and sterols are all “important for healthy yeast growth, reproduction and survival as heat and alcohol increase in fermentation.” 
  • Ethanol toxicity -- According to Jackson, S. cerevisiae is highly tolerant of alcohol toxicity but increasing alcohol buildup eventually inhibits fermentation by suppression of sugar uptake.
  • Low pH -- Cerevisiae is tolerant to low pH. According to Bisson, it can grow in the range of 2.8 to 4.2 but growth and fermentation are significantly affected at levels below 2.8.
  • Temperature extremes – According to Jackson, the growth rate of yeast cells is strongly influenced by temperature, with experiments showing significant reductions in cell division for every 10 degrees C increase in temperature. Excessively high temperature affects membrane fluidity and, therefore, transporter performance, and may induce stuck fermentations. Red wines are typically fermented between 24 and 27 degrees C. Dr. Murli Dharmadhikari (Lactic Acid Bacteria and Wine Spoilage, extension.iastate.edu) admonishes us to not allow fermentation temperatures to rise above 30℃. According to A.P. Haynk (The control of temperature in wine fermentation, July 1897), “For normal must with a normal yeast, the death point is 98-100℉ (36.6℃+). Before this point, however, the yeast stops working and bacteria begins to grow.
  • Zymostatic and zymocidal toxins – Killer factors, molds, organic and medium-chain fatty acids, and fungicides and pesticides used in the vineyard are all cited by Bisson as potentially toxic to the yeast during fermentation. 
  • Microbiological activity – This is the biggest source of volatile acidity. Could be triggered by wild yeasts, malolactic bacteria and acetic bacteria (Wynboer.co.za). Fermentations which include high populations of non-Saccharomyces yeast and bacteria are at risk of arrest because of the competition for nutrients plus the production of inhibitory factors. According to Bisson, some Saccharomyces strains are especially subject to inhibition by malolactic bacteria. An arrested fermentation of this type requires that the compromised biomass be removed in order to attempt re-starting the fermentation.
  • Acetic acid -- There seems to be some confusion in the literature as to the role of acetic acid in stuck fermentations. According to Eglinton and Henschke, “Acetic acid toxicity has been suggested as a cause of stuck fermentation because it can inhibit the growth and fermentation activity of S. cerevisiae.” Rasmussen et al. (Acetic Acid as a Causative Agent in Producing Stuck Fermentations, AJEV 46(2), 1995), showed that removal of acetic acid from stuck lots with a Vinovation process resulted in prompt re-initiation of fermentation. Adding inoculants to the lots further “advanced “ the re-fermentation process. On the other side of the coin, Dr. Dharmadhikari notes “serious spoilage” occurring in musts with stuck fermentations because lactic acid bacteria can attack sugar (according to Dr. Daharmadhikari, lactic acid bacteria metabolizes sugars such as glucose and sucrose and produces lactic and acetic acid as by-products) and increase the VA levels in the wine. Bisson and Butzke see elevated levels of acetic acid leading to a stuck fermentation but they see that as a result of a problem fermentation rather than as the cause. In other words, the problem fermentation has some underlying cause which itself leads to elevated levels of acetic acid production and a stuck fermentation. In that case, getting rid of the acetic acid will still not have solved the underlying problem.
According to Bisson and Butzke, “The consensus strategy for re-initiation of stuck fermentations involves first removal of the settled yeast biomass followed by re-inoculation with a starter ‘adapted’ to the arrested environment.” Removal of the settled yeast biomass is accomplished by racking the wine off the lees and this will, in some cases, lead to a spontaneous restart of the fermentation. The conditions which are alleviated by racking off the lees are (Bisson and Butzke):
  • Sterol or fatty acid limitation
  • Exposure to temperature extremes. 
If there are no other contributing limitations (and, in the case of extreme temperature, once the temperature is restored to an acceptable range), racking will, in some cases, lead to a spontaneous re-initiation of stuck ferments. If, for example, one of the above limitations is combined with nitrogen or micronutrient limitations, racking alone will not suffice (Bisson and Butzke). 


©Wine -- Mise en abyme